Thursday, March 26, 2009

Proud of My Fellow Domers


In defense of the unborn, we wish to express our deepest opposition to Reverend John I. Jenkins, CSC’s invitation of President Barack Obama to be the University of Notre Dame’s principal commencement speaker and the recipient of an honorary degree. Our objection is not a matter of political partisanship, but of President Obama’s hostility to the Catholic Church’s teachings on the sanctity of human life at its earliest stages. His recent dedication of federal funds to overseas abortions and to embryonic stem cell research will directly result in the deaths of thousands of innocent human beings.

We cannot sit by idly while the University honors someone who believes that an entire class of human beings is undeserving of the most basic of all legal rights, the right to live.The University’s decision runs counter to the policy of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops against honoring pro-choice politicians. In their June 2004 statement Catholics in Political Life, the bishops said, “The Catholic community and Catholic institutions should not honor those who act in defiance of our fundamental moral principles. They should not be given awards, honors, or platforms which would suggest support for their actions.”

Fr. Jenkins defends his invitation by saying that it does not honor or suggest support for the President’s views on abortion, but rather support for his leadership. But our “fundamental moral principles” must be respected at all times. And the principle that requires us to refrain from the direct killing of the innocent has a special status even among the most fundamental principles. President Obama’s actions have consistently shown contempt for this principle, and he has sought political gain by making light of its clear political implications. Leadership that puts the lives of the most innocent at risk is leadership we must disdain. In the face of President Obama’s actions, Father Jenkins’ words ring hollow.

It is a great irony that the University has chosen to award President Obama an honorary law degree. As the oldest Catholic law school in the country, the Notre Dame Law School states that its mission is “to facilitate greater understanding of and commitment to the relationship between law and social justice.” The social justice issue of our day is the deliberate, legal attack on the most vulnerable members of society, the unborn. To award a Notre Dame law degree to a lawyer and politician who has used the law to deny equality to the unborn diminishes the value of the degree itself.

Additionally, Fr. Jenkins has placed some of his students in a moral dilemma as to whether they can attend their own graduation. Many pro-life seniors, along with their families, are conflicted about whether to participate in the commencement ceremony. The lack of concern for these devoted sons and daughters of Notre Dame, who love this University and the Catholic principles on which it was built, is shameful.

In response to the University’s decision, we pledge ourselves to acts of witness that will be characterized by respect, prayerfulness, outspoken fidelity to the Church, and true concern for the good of our University.It is appropriate that only members of the Notre Dame community lead all such protests, and we ask outside groups to respect our responsibilities in this regard. Over the next several weeks, in response to this scandal, our organizations will host various academic and religious events to engage the University community. We request any groups who are committed to respectful actions to support our efforts, thereby ensuring a unified front and a more compelling public witness.

In Notre Dame,

Notre Dame Right to Life
The Irish Rover Student Newspaper
Notre Dame College Republicans
The University of Notre Dame Anscombe Society
Notre Dame Identity Project
Militia of the Immaculata
Children of Mary
Orestes Brownson Council
Notre Dame Law School Right to Life
Notre Dame Law St Thomas More Society
The Federalist Society at Notre Dame Law School

The web site for this coalition of Notre dame Students is


Jeremy Priest said...

This is a really nice piece over at First Things by Stephen M. Barr entitled, Fr. Jenkins, Please Engage Us!

It sets out the basic arguments and pleads with Fr. Jenkins to enter into the dialogue he speaks about.

Anonymous said...

This may seem like a cheap shot, but would you have made the same fuss if it was Bush rather than Obama? Or is abortion the only the issue that you folks ever get excited about?

Randy said...

President Bush had a much better track record (not perfect) then Obama.

Plus, if abortion is truely a killing of an innocent child (which it is!!!!!), why wouldn't we cry in digust at it? this includes embryonic stem cell research too. Obama's position on it doesn't make sense, because there are numerous treatments with adult stem cells and embryonic stem cells can be made with ordinary skin cells. So why take the route where human beings are killed and no moral/ethical boundaries are crossed? Curious isn't it?

Notre Dame is a Catholic institution. As such you would hope it would bring in as speakers people who reflect Catholic values.

Unknown said...

Hey Brant,
I keep seeing a commercial on EWTN advertising that you will be on (I think on the "Life on the Rock" show), but every time they say your name and have your name flash on the screen, they show a guest who is definitely NOT you. I laugh every time I see it!

Randy said...

I should have said "So why take the route where human beings are killed and moral/ethical boundaries are crossed? Curious isn't it?"

Instead of "So why take the route where human beings are killed and NO moral/ethical boundaries are crossed? Curious isn't it?"

Sister Mary Agnes said...

The above link is a really good interview by Zenit with Mariangela Sullivan, founder and director of Notre Dame Action Coalition. I highly recommend this article for further reading on this issue.

Sister Mary Agnes said...

Here is another really good article through Zenit. Helen M. Alvare really tears apart the Notre Dame administration's "reasons" for honoring Obama.